RACGP
Aleisha Orr

Aleisha Orr

Private health insurers 'must not compromise integrity of Medicare' - RACGP

Billing decisions should always be at the discretion of GPs and not be influenced by the involvement of private health insurers, GPs have said.

Concerns about ‘managed care’ as Bupa makes moves in primary health

It comes amid reports staff at a GP clinic operated by Bupa were encouraged to bill more expensive Medicare items.

Staff at the clinic were sent an email which told doctors to ensure revenue was rising, suggesting this could be done by increasing the number of chronic condition management plans (CCMP), the ABC reported.

RACGP WA Chair Julia Rawlinson said there would always be a bit of conflict of interest when corporate organisations are involved with clinics, but profit should not be the “sole lens” doctors use when considering how to bill patients.

She said she worried emails like the one reported would put pressure on GPs.

“Really, anything that’s billed through the GP is at the discretion of the GP and needs to comply with the criteria and intent that that item number is determined for,” she said.

“Chronic condition management plans, when they are used appropriately for patients that fit the criteria, are very useful tools to manage and hopefully get better outcomes for for chronic diseases.

“That doesn’t mean companies should be encouraging GPs to bill item numbers because the chronic condition management plan rebates are higher than than a standard consult.”

AD

Private health insurer Bupa has made moves into primary care in recent years, announcing in 2025 that it would begin delivering a network of 60 mental health clinics across the country.

In July this year it announced it would be taking over a number of WA medical clinics after it acquired Partnered Health.

The RACGP updated its position statement on the role of private health insurance in healthcare on Tuesday, in which it asserted that any involvement in primary care must not compromise universal access, equity or the integrity of Medicare.

The College stated that access to high-quality general practice care should be based on need, not an individual’s capacity to pay or health insurance status.

"Some private health insurers (PHI) have been offering faster access to GPs for their members, often via online programs,” the statement said.

"Any similar PHI pilot projects or programs must not result in patients who are insured being given priority or preferential access to primary healthcare services over patients without insurance who may have greater need."

AD

It made clear the College does not support amendments to the Private Health Insurance Act that would allow PHIs to fund services already covered by Medicare or to cover gap payments.

"Such changes could compromise universal access to general practice and primary healthcare, and risk creating inequities that oppose the RACGP’s commitment to a fair and accessible health system."

It also stated that services facilitated by PHIs must integrate with, and enhance, GP-led care, following the principles set out in its Vision for general practice and a sustainable healthcare system.

A spokesperson for Bupa said treating doctors decide whether a service is clinically appropriate and necessary, and whether relevant Medicare requirements have been met.

They did not comment on how often GPs were given guidance on billing and profits.

“Any patient on a CCMP has been placed on one because it is clinically appropriate and provides them with the best framework to manage any long-term or terminal health conditions," they said.

“Our practice managers provide administrative support to our doctors. Patient needs, clinical judgement, and compliance with Medicare requirements always come first and we reinforce this through ongoing guidance and training."

AD