RACGP
Aleisha Orr

Aleisha Orr

WA's Department of Health 'lacks strategy and blurs lines of responsibility'

A scathing review into how the WA Department of Health is run has found it lacking an overarching strategy.

Arrows in different directions

The Agency Capability Review, undertaken by the Public Sector Commission, found the department's role had blurred beyond its intended purpose and that no overall plan to lead the department was in place.

A former WA Health employee, who did not want to be named, told Medical Forum the findings within the report were "damning".

The Commission was unable to identify a comprehensive strategy within the department, something the former employee said reflected the reasons many doctors within the state's public system were "incredibly frustrated" by.

The review focused on the department as distinct from WA Health. Similar reviews have been carried out of other government departments.

“The agency needs a plan to lead a system as large and complex as WA Health, however the review was not able to locate such a plan," it stated.

The department was also found to have "prioritised operational system management and whole of system outcomes at the expense of its own corporate capability".

While the department's role is defined through legislation as one of stewardship, the review found it had moved beyond this towards one of health service provider operational management.

AD

The report warned this “blurs accountability between the agency and health service providers".

It also found that issues with governance, roles and responsibilities had resulted in unclear boundaries, duplications and inefficiencies.

Medical Forum's source pointed to the creation of the State Health Operations Centre of an example of this.

"They are talking around operationally driving things like ramping and ambulance management, but what the report is saying is that's not the department's job, the department's job is to set a strategy, set a mission, help people get there, hold the services to account," they said.

"Whereas the department's not doing any of those things. Instead it is taking an interest in moving ambulances around the system and so on, which are never department functions, that's not what it's been set up to do."

The review identified a pattern of similar types of performance issues being raised over time through multiple reviews, indicating a failure to act on implementing improvements in a consistent way.

“A disciplined process for prioritising recommendations and delivering agreed reforms is needed, particularly given the agency’s responsibilities for delivering on government priorities and on recommendations from reviews and reports, past and present,” it found.

AD

The department's reliance on the 2019 Sustainable Health Review to guide reform for the system was also highlighted as a concern, with the report pointing out this was now seven years old and that the system had changed.

Medical Forum put a number of questions to the department to which a response was provided on behalf of a WA Health spokesperson.

They did not refute the department lacked a strategy or provide responses as to how the specific issues raised in the review were being addressed.

"Many of the areas identified for development are already being progressed through strengthened governance arrangements, workforce and financial planning, and work to establish a clear strategic direction for the department and broader public health sector," the spokesperson said.

"The review comes at a time of significant population growth, rapid technological transformation and increased demand on health services, highlighting the importance of strong leadership, collaboration and a coordinated approach to health system challenges."

They added the 2019 Sustainable Health Review remained relevant and continued to provide an important foundation for health system reform.

"The department will carefully consider the recommendations outlined in the review and continue working with staff, health service providers, government agencies and external stakeholders to strengthen its leadership and improve health outcomes," the spokesperson said.

AD